The best mascara for length and volume, I’ve ventured into the expansive realm of lash enhancers, each promising a unique extra length, curl, or that coveted Twiggy-inspired spidery effect. Amidst the myriad options, one steadfast choice remains volumizing mascaras, the unsung heroes that effortlessly thicken and plump lashes, creating a falsies effect without the hassle of lash glue.
In my exploration of the perfect mascara, I’ve uncovered that volumizing mascaras offer more than just a dramatic look. Makeup artist Tony Tulve attests to their versatility, describing them as a quick and effort-free way to draw attention to the eyes, even on eyeliner-free days. Beyond that, they serve as an excellent foundation for false lashes, imparting a natural smokiness and definition to the eyes. What’s more, many volumizing mascaras boast built-in lengthening and curling benefits.
9 Best Mascara For Length and Volume | Lightweight Mascara
Waterproof Mascara | Volumizing Mascaras
I’ve undertaken exhaustive research in our Manhattan-based Lab to guide you through the labyrinth of options. Through real-life testing, I’ve scrutinized each mascara’s benefits, shades, waterproof capabilities, and the extent to which it lifts and plumps lashes. Clumping and wand design were also pivotal considerations. With insights from a celebrity makeup artist, we’ve curated a list of top-rated fan favorites.
Join me in this exploration of the best 27 mascaras, placing a spotlight on the sought-after ‘best mascara for length and volume.’ From the convenience of volumizing formulas to the nuances of wand design, we’ll navigate the world of mascaras poised to redefine your lash game.
1. Best Overall: Covergirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- A go-to choice for almost every bridal client, consistently delivering without irritation.
- The creamy formula remains smooth, avoiding dryness or flaking.
- Affordable price with excellent value.
- Unique screw-cap wand ensures precise application for volume and length.
- No smudging or flaking, making it a favorite drugstore beauty treat.
What I Don’t Love:
- Challenging to remove.
- Noticeable fragrance.
2. Best Lengthening Mascara : Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
Why Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara Worth It:
- All-star formula secures its place in the internet’s lash hall of fame.
- Hourglass-shaped brush for excellent buildability.
- Faultless performance during testing, earning the ‘Runner Up’ award.
- Can be built up for high drama or applied with a single coat for a natural yet defined look.
- The non-waterproof formula adheres without smudging, simplifying removal.
What I Don’t Love:
- The tube contains less product than others.
3. Best volumizing mascaras: YSL Beauty Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils
Why It’s Worth It:
- Buildable mascara creates a dramatic, false-lash look.
- The intense black formula thickens and lengthens lashes for an insane fanned-out definition.
- Infused with Moroccan argan oil and provitamin B5 for lash conditioning.
- Don’t smudge or flake during wear.
- Removal requires effort with micellar water and cotton pads.
What I Don’t Love:
- Hard to remove.
4. Best Lengthening mascara in Budget: Essence Cosmetics Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Beloved by beauty gurus and the Byrdie staff, lifting and lengthening lashes at a fraction of the price.
- It stayed put during testing, resisting smudging, flakiness, and residue.
- Lightweight and easy-to-handle sculpting wand effortlessly separates lashes.
- Affordable and impressive, making it a standout in my beauty routine.
What I Don’t Love:
- Doesn’t curl lashes and can clump on the brush.
5. Best for Fuller Lashes: Charlotte Tilbury Full Fat Lashes Mascara
Why Charlotte Tilbury Full-Fat Lashes Mascara Worth It:
- Buildable mascara that lengthens, curls, and boosts volume.
- Five-grooved brush deposits formula along the lash line for a fuller look.
- Easy removal process, adding to its appeal.
What I Don’t Love:
- Doesn’t define individual lashes.
6. Best For Sensitive Eyes: ILIA Beauty Limitless Lash Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Mascara offers a comfortable experience, tested by ophthalmologists and contact wearers.
- Gentle formula, free from controversial ingredients, uses keratin to fortify and shea butter to condition.
- Strong pigment easily coats each lash, providing length and boldness with one swipe.
- Dual-side applicator enhances performance, offering curl, volume, length, and separation options.
What I Don’t Love:
- Smaller tube size.
7. Best Overall Drugstore: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Waterproof Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Iconic mascara consistently delivers thick, fluttery, and bold lashes.
- There is a broad selection of color options and availability in traditional and waterproof formulas.
- Affordable and reliable, standing the test of time.
What I Don’t Love:
- Formula can be stubborn and hard to remove.
8. Best Splurge: Chanel Le Volume Révolution de Chanel Extreme Volume Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Fantastic volume, lift, and definition.
- A patented 3D-printed brush with a honeycomb-like design ensures a smooth application without clumps.
- Perfect amount of mascara without chunking up, resulting in smooth, soft, and natural-looking lashes.
- Impressive all-day lift.
What I Don’t Love:
- Product buildup can occur in the brush.
9. Best Drugstore for Plumping: Neutrogena Hydro Boost Plumping Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Affordable formula enriched with hyaluronic acid, keratin, and vitamin E.
- The glossy formula provides a daily volumizing effect while strengthening and nourishing lashes.
- Great for those who prefer a glossier formula with moderate volume for everyday wear.
What I Don’t Love:
- May not provide insane volume for those seeking a bold look.
10. Best for Fullness: Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara
Why Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara Worth It:
- Jumbo brush and nylon microfibers deliver bold, full lashes.
- Lovely color options cater to different preferences.
- The mascara’s ability to feather out the ends while adding volume at the roots is a standout feature.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some individuals with sensitive eyes may find it itchy or irritating.
11. Kosas The Big Clean Volumizing + Lash Care Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- As a fan of clean beauty, Kosas impresses with a formula tested by ophthalmologists. The mascara creates a full and fluffy lash, thanks to lash-boosting peptides, castor oil, and panthenol.
What I Don’t Love:
- Potential transfer issues may occur, especially for those with oily lids.
12. MAC Macstack Superstack Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- MAC Cosmetics delivers extreme volume with a buildable mascara that doesn’t clump. The molded brush ensures bold pigment deposition and volume without sacrificing a natural look.
What I Don’t Love:
- Individuals with oily skin might experience a “raccoon eye” effect on the lower lash line.
13. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer
Why It’s Worth It:
- Honest Beauty’s mascara, a winner of the 2023 Readers’ Choice Award, combines moisturizing and lengthening benefits. The mascara’s longevity, even after a few margaritas, makes it a standout choice.
Who It’s For:
- Suitable for anyone and everyone seeking a mascara that delivers.
14. Lancôme Définicils High Definition Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Winner of multiple Allure Awards, Lancôme Définicils provides a natural-looking lash transformation. The long, thin brush ensures precise application.
What I Don’t Love:
- May not be suitable for those seeking bold, dramatic lashes.
15. Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- A TikTok sensation, Maybelline’s mascara offers fluttery long lashes without breaking the bank. The flexible wand ensures even application.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some users reported difficulties with removal.
16. Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Winner of the Best of Beauty Breakthrough Award, Benefit’s mascara uses magnetically charged technology for Lengthening mascara without clumps.
What I Don’t Love:
- May be challenging to remove.
17. Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Blinc’s tubing mascara provides length and volume without smudging. The unique wand ensures drama without clumps.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some users may find the tubing effect unconventional.
18. Nars Climax Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Nars’s Climax Mascara offers a buildable, flexible formula, making it a go-to for enhancing thin, wispy lashes.
What I Don’t Love:
- May cause irritation for those with sensitive eyes.
19. Revlon So Fierce! Big Bad Lash Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- A flake-free, 24-hour formula that adds volume and features color-depositing technology for gradual darkening of lashes.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some users reported a bit of clumping.
20. Milk Makeup Kush High Volumizing Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Vegan and cruelty-free, Milk Makeup‘s mascara contains heart-shaped fibers for longer and fuller lashes.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some users may find the formula too wet.
21. Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Full Frontal Volume, Lift & Curl Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Fenty Beauty’s mascara boasts a unique wand for volume, lift, and curl. Water-resistant and featuring a flat/fat wand design.
What I Don’t Love:
- The wand design may not be suitable for everyone.
22. Tower 28 Beauty MakeWaves Lengthening + Volumizing Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Tiny yet mighty bristles deliver transformative results in both length and volume. Water-resistant and humidity-proof.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some users may find the bristles too small for their liking.
23. URBAN DECAY Perversion volumizing mascaras
Why It’s Worth It:
- Urban Decay’s mascara features a brush that grabs hair at the root, providing bold lashes. Contains hardens for lash growth stimulation.
What I Don’t Love:
- Maybe on the pricier side.
24. TreStiQue Good Vibes Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Combining a curling mascara and a compact curler, TreStiQue offers a convenient hybrid for on-the-go makeup applications.
What I Don’t Love:
- Not water-resistant or smudge-proof.
25. Benefit Cosmetics BadGal Bang! volumizing mascaras
Why It’s Worth It:
- Benefit’s mascara uses light ingredients for voluminous lashes without the heavy feel. The long-wear formula for extended wear.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some reviewers say the wand picks up a lot of formula, so it’s best to wipe off the excess on the rim before applying.
26. L’Oreal Paris Unlimited Lash Lifting and Lengthening mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Featuring an adjustable wand for customized application, L’Oreal Paris Unlimited allows easy coating of every lash for lift and length.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some reviewers say the formula can feel overly thick and dry.
27. Kaja Wink Lash Trio Mascara
Why It’s Worth It:
- Kaja’s mascara trio offers a comprehensive solution with a clear primer, a lengthening mascara, and a volumizing mascaras.
What I Don’t Love:
- Some reviewers say the volumizing mascaras is a bit clumpy.
Conclusion
This mascara odyssey has been a fascinating exploration of beauty’s transformative power. From trusted classics like L’Oréal Paris Voluminous to luxurious indulgences in Chanel’s Volume Révolution, each wand and formula held a unique promise. Neutrogena surprised with its nourishing touch, while Dior’s bold statement left a lasting impression. Kosas catered to sensitive eyes, and MAC’s buildable magic added layers without clumps.
Honest Beauty’s longevity stood out, a testament to its award-winning formula. Lancôme Définicils embraced a natural look, and Maybelline’s budget-friendly flutter became a TikTok sensation. Benefit’s magnetic breakthrough and Blinc’s tubing magic showcased innovation, while Nars catered to sensitive eyes.
From drugstore finds to high-end splurges, each mascara brought something special to the table. As the mascara journey continues, my lashes have witnessed volume, length, and curl. Whether it’s a clear primer from Kaja or the volumizing lightness of Benefit Cosmetics BadGal Bang!, this odyssey celebrates the diverse world of lashes and the artistry each mascara bottle holds. May your mascara wand always be your beauty wand, painting stories of allure and confidence with every swipe.
What is the best overall mascara recommended in the article?
In my experience, the best overall mascara is the Covergirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof mascara. It’s affordable, smudge-proof, and adds significant volume without clumping.
Is there a mascara that provides both length and curl?
Absolutely! The Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is a fantastic choice. It not only adds length to lashes but also curls and plumps at the root, giving a full and volumizing mascaras look.
Which mascara is known for its defining effect and dramatic look?
The YSL Beauty Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils is renowned for its ability to create a dramatic, false-lash effect. It has great color payoff and is easy to apply, making lashes look bold and defined.
Is there a budget-friendly mascara that still delivers great results?
For those on a budget, the Essence Cosmetics Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is a go-to choice. It’s affordable, layers easily, and adds significant length to lashes.
What mascara is recommended for fuller lashes and a glossy finish?
The Charlotte Tilbury Full Fat Lashes Mascara is ideal for achieving fuller lashes with a glossy finish. It’s buildable and provides a voluminous look without flaking.
Which mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes?
If you have sensitive eyes, the ILIA Beauty Limitless Lash Mascara is a great option. It nourishes lashes, separates them, and adds length without causing irritation.
What is a classic and reliable Waterproof mascara?
The L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Waterproof Mascara is a classic choice that stands the test of time. It offers incredible volume and comes in a variety of shades.
Are there any high-end mascaras worth the splurge?
Absolutely! The Chanel Le Volume Révolution de Chanel Extreme volumizing mascaras is a splurge-worthy option. It provides fantastic volume, lift, and definition.
Is there a good drugstore mascara with lash-nourishing ingredients?
Yes, the Neutrogena Hydro Boost Plumping Mascara is an affordable option with hyaluronic acid, keratin, and vitamin E to plump and nourish lashes.
Which mascara is known for its tubing formula and long-lasting wear?
The Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara is an excellent choice for a tubing formula. It provides long-lasting wear without clumping or flaking.
What is the best mascara for a natural look that enhances lashes without being too dramatic?
If you prefer a more natural look, the Honest Beauty Extreme Lengthening mascara + Lash Primer is a great choice. It adds subtle length without being overly dramatic.
Which mascara is recommended for someone who wants natural-looking lashes with a defined separation?
The Nars Climax Mascara is perfect for achieving natural-looking lashes with a gentle volumizing effect and precise separation.
Is there a tubing mascara that provides both length and volume without smudging?
Yes, the Kjaer Weis Lengthening mascara is a tubing mascara that offers impressive length and volume while staying smudge-free throughout the day.
What mascara is known for its long-lasting formula, making it suitable for all-day wear?
For long-lasting wear, the Urban Decay Perversion volumizing mascaras is a top choice. It features a jet-black formula that stays put without smudging.
Can you recommend a mascara that’s great for layering and building up volume?
The MAC Macstack Superstack Mascara is perfect for layering, allowing you to build up volume without clumping. It’s a flake-free formula that delivers fantastic results.
What is the best mascara for someone who wears contacts and has sensitive eyes?
The Milk Makeup Kush High volumizing mascaras are vegan, cruelty-free, and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, providing both length and volume.
Which mascara is known for its unique brush design that adjusts for different application styles?
The L’Oreal Paris Unlimited Lash Lifting and Lengthening mascara has an adjustable wand that allows you to customize your application style for every lash.
Is there a mascara that offers a three-in-one solution for lashes and brows?
Yes, the Kaja Wink Lash Trio Mascara is a versatile option with clear primer, lengthening mascara, and volumizing mascaras, also suitable for brows.
Can you recommend a Lightweight mascara that provides volume without weighing down lashes?
The Benefit Cosmetics BadGal Bang! volumizing mascaras is incredibly light, offering instant volume without the heavy feeling on lashes.
Which mascara is known for its flexible wand, making it easy to coat every lash?
The L’Oreal Paris Unlimited Lash Lifting and Lengthening Mascara features an adjustable wand that makes it easy to coat every lash, providing lift and length.
6 thoughts on “My Personal Reviews For 27 Best Mascara For Length and Volume that gives you Full Dramatic and Fluttery Lashes”
Comments are closed.